E-PASS IT ON!® 2004

The On-Line Journal of The Children's Music Network

What Can Music Give — Your Thoughts? 

by Barb Tilsen

Over the past few years, The Children's Music Network (CMN) has been exploring relevant questions about the impact of music in children's lives. The connecting threads in these conversations raise important themes that we invite you to explore in this first edition of e-PIO!. This editorial space will be a place to hear what you think in answer to these questions. In the coming months, we'll post people's responses. Please share your thoughts! We invite members of CMN and non-members as well to contribute.

Pete Seeger has spoken in our CMN conferences about how "We used to be a singing nation." Children grew up in homes whose living rooms had upright pianos, at schools where they regularly sang in classrooms, and in lively community celebrations where people made music together. The role that songs played in the development of community and in the promotion of positive social skills was profound. Bob Blue has noted that in almost every other culture, singing, dancing, and playing instruments is part of work, family, school, and recreation. What happened here? In the last fifty years, our society has moved away from music-making that is interwoven throughout community life. Television, movies and recordings have all served to erode a once-central tradition of communal singing. Some of the conversations at our gatherings and on our CMN member e-mail list have been devoted to this trend in our culture toward passive listeners rather than active singers and the impact of new technologies and the corporate music scene.

Through the CMN e-mail list and especially in Steven Schuch's great article "Reflections on the Nature of Arts and Education" which appears here in e-PIO!, we have had dialogues about the character of our educational system and the positive impact the arts in general and music in particular have on learning. We've voiced serious concerns about the cutbacks in our schools, the impact that the predominance of testing and the No Child Left Behind policy have had on children and on the arts in the schools. We've talked about what children need to be learning now in this coming age of world violence and scarcity, with more and more of our world resources at stake, exploited by corporate powers. At one of our CMN conferences a few years ago, folklorist Bess Lomax Hawes spoke eloquently about how children learn songs that they hold inside in their own "song bag." These songs are there ready as a balm and as a tool for dealing with powerful and emotional moments when children need them later on.

These reflections lead to other important questions. What is music uniquely able to give children that helps equip them to face the future? What does it give us as a community? What are we losing as a nation when we stop singing together? What skills and what ways of thinking and problem-solving are at stake? How can we help children prepare and learn skills about cooperation and sharing, problem-solving as a group, thinking with the collective good in mind? What can music contribute more readily and effectively than anything else?

Please send your thoughts to office@cmnonline.org. We will select all or parts of responses received and post them in this current issue of e-PIO!

Back to e-PIO! 2004